When it comes to trading quarterbacks in the NFL, few deals spark as much debate as the one involving Deshaun Watson and the Cleveland Browns. Imagine the audacity of considering which quarterbacks might command a similar monumental trade package! As we delve into this topic, a recent rumor about the Miami Dolphins' ambitious bid for Joe Burrow adds another layer to the discussion.
On December 20, 2025, reports surfaced that the Dolphins proposed an astonishing offer to the Cincinnati Bengals: four first-round draft picks to secure the rights to draft Burrow in 2020. Unsurprisingly, the Bengals rejected this overture outright, refusing even to discuss a potential trade. But let’s not allow that to deter our curiosity!
So, if the Browns were to contemplate making a comparable offer—let's say four first-round picks like the Dolphins considered—how many quarterbacks in the league would actually be deemed worthy of such an investment? Some fans might argue that none are worth that steep price tag, but let’s explore this further.
Here’s a list of quarterbacks who could arguably merit such a hefty deal, presented without a specific ranking. We invite you to weigh in with your perspectives in the comments below:
- Jordan Love: Although he has displayed inconsistency, his youth and potential, coupled with team success, make him intriguing.
- Dak Prescott: Now at 32, Prescott has yet to elevate the Cowboys to significant heights, despite impressive statistics.
- Drake Maye: He’s emerging as a likely MVP candidate, but he lacks extensive proof of his capabilities.
- Patrick Mahomes: At 30 years old, Mahomes has accumulated considerable experience and accolades, placing him in discussions about the greatest of all time (GOAT).
- Josh Allen: An elite talent, Allen has faced challenges during playoffs, which might temper his perceived value.
- Lamar Jackson: Another elite quarterback, Jackson has showcased his skills but has also dealt with playoff struggles and injury concerns.
- Justin Herbert: Despite impressive numbers, Herbert is still seeking his first playoff victory, having faced setbacks last postseason.
- Jalen Hurts: With two Super Bowl appearances and one victory under his belt, Hurts’ ability to lead raises questions about whether his success is due to team strength or his own talent.
- Caleb Williams: He possesses immense upside and is showing improvement in his second year, but his limited history makes him a riskier bet.
- Trevor Lawrence: After a challenging start, Lawrence seems to have unlocked his potential in 2025 under a new offensive scheme, prompting speculation about his future.
- Joe Burrow: Frequently plagued by injuries, Burrow has still performed exceptionally well when healthy, leading the Bengals to a Super Bowl appearance.
- Jayden Daniels: His promising rookie season was overshadowed by injuries in his second year, although his potential remains evident.
So, who else deserves a spot on this list? And among these quarterbacks, how many would genuinely warrant three or four first-round picks from the Browns or any other team? We would love to hear your thoughts, whether you agree or disagree, in the comments section!
